yelp%25252520five%25252520star_edited_edited_edited_edited.jpg

Testimonials

Thank you for Sharing the love!!

Thank You for all the FIVE star reviews. It means the world to us that you enjoy eating our cuisine as much as we relish the opportunity to serve you. We take pride in our product and appreciate the time you take to write such kind words.
We look forward to seeing you again soon.
Grazie Mille!

"My my goodness! The Mad Sicilian is all about goodness....no....greatness! Growing up in New York I loved my Sicilian style pizza but never did I have one this delicious. The crust is amazing. Light yet so flavorful with the perfect texture and crunch. The tomato sauce was so very flavorful and was on top of the cheese which we liked. Owner and pizza maker extraordinaire, George, informed us that this was a Sicilian tradition to keep the sauce from moistening the crust. Brilliant! It worked perfectly!
We added roasted garlic which was superb.
And then dessert! My wife loves cannolis and she was mightily impressed by the homemade treat here. Just beautifully prepared and absolutely delicious without being overly sweet.
George also gifted us his lemon tart which was divine. Also homemade in this gem of a place.
The service was outstanding. Great big smiles from Naomi and efficient polite service.
This is now one of our favorite places in Petaluma."

Eric S.

“Ordered a Sicilian and a large Chicago Style last night for pick up. Both were ready within 40 minutes as promised. Driving home, the aroma took me back to Gino's East in downtown Chicago, I was excited to try a slice (or 3).

At home, we favored the Chicago style which was a true cheese pie with sauce you might find in Chicagoland, but with a crust that was more reminiscent of the Bay Area rather than traditional cornmeal crust, which was a good thing. Appreciated having them score the top and not cut through to prevent the cheese from making a mess. I actually had leftovers for lunch today, still tasted great!

The Sicilian had the right bread/crust texture and good flavor.

Kicking myself for not picking up the chocolate mousse, given the reviews. . .”   

Steve R., Petaluma, Ca.

"I drove out all the way from San Rafael to grab a deep dish from the Mad Sicilian! Let me tell you it was worth it! This pizza had some weight too it.

Once I got it home I popped it back in the oven and cut myself a slice, oh sooo cheesy. Just like when I visited Chicago IL.

And you have to try the Cannolis. It's a family recipe and they're awesome! I should have bought more than one!"

David G., San Rafael, CA

“The half classic, half pepperoni Sicilian was exquisite. It's loaded with sauce and cheese, the top edge of the crust was crunchy, and the middle crust was deliciously chewy. Perfect for a family of 4, or a hungry couple!”

Jeff S., Petaluma, Ca.

“Fantastic Sicilian Pizza!!!!!
Delicious!  Thought we were in Palermo!!
Fresh and Tasty Desserts!
A Welcome New Addition to Petaluma!
Salute!”

The Scutari's, North Beach, San Francisco, Ca.

“Love their Chicago Style!
It had a lot of flavors, super thick and cheesy. Everything seems to be handmade and tasted amazing.
Recommend this place for sure. Come support a local and try out their whole menu.”   

Miguel F., Petaluma, Ca.

"Diggin' it. Hello Zachary's. Chicago is real deal. Adding to the menu that satisfies my roots. Had polenta and meatballs. While not as orgasmatron as old Rosso's, it felt more homestyle and that was great too."

Evan P.

"My husband and I just ordered for the first time. Our pizza smelled, looked, and tasted amazing! The employees were so friendly and made our food great. We will definitely be back soon!"

Michelle Yonkers

"New pizzeria in the Plaza North shipping center next to Starbucks. Tried a piece of their deep dish during the soft opening and it's legit!"

"I order an extra deep dish for the freezer and it's dinner all week! So good."

"Their deep dish is some seriously delicous pie"